Prosecution discontinued following abuse of process argument
Louise’s 16-year-old client was a well-known victim of modern slavery with no less than three separate conclusive grounds decisions confirming long-term child criminal exploitation. Despite representations from the defence to discontinue the proceedings, and disclosure arguments which laid bare the authorities’ failure to investigate his exploitation and their failure to keep him safe, the Crown insisted on continuing his prosecution for possession of a bladed article. Only after service of Louise’s abuse of process argument, which highlighted the authorities’ Article 4 and 6 violations, the Crown finally discontinued the proceedings.
Louise’s client had only just turned 16 when he was found in possession of a sword, which he had been holding for his exploiter. Her client was psychologically extremely vulnerable and was highly suggestible. His childhood had been characterised by abuse, trauma, and separation, and had very precarious living arrangements at the time of the exploitation. As recognised several times in his conclusive grounds decisions, his exploiters had been taking advantage of his extremely vulnerable profile to push him into child criminal exploitation.
More than a year before he committed the offence, the police and social workers had started reporting incidents of exploitation and he received his first conclusive grounds decision about six months earlier. Despite being well-known to the authorities as a victim of modern slavery, Louise’s client received minimal assistance, and his families’ requests to move him away from his exploiters were not actioned. When he was arrested with the sword, the police immediately noted that this was likely to be child criminal exploitation. However, this was never investigated, and he was prosecuted instead.
In her abuse skeleton, Louise detailed the police and the CPS’ many Article 4 and Article 6 failures. She also highlighted the Crown’s poor and factually incorrect reasons for continuing his prosecution. The Crown ultimately discontinued the prosecution days before the abuse of process application was to be heard.
Louise Willocx was instructed by Kiya Mazur of Bindmans.



