Share:

Secretary of State for Justice downgrades Category A prisoner following two settled claims for judicial review and is ordered by High Court to pay costs

Rabah Kherbane represented G, a life-sentenced prisoner, in two claims for judicial review of refusals by the Secretary of State for Justice to downgrade his Category A security categorisation without an oral hearing. After the High Court granted permission on all grounds, G was downgraded. Following contested written submissions, the High Court unusually ordered the Secretary of State to pay G’s costs.

G had been a Category A prisoner for more than twelve years and had never had an oral hearing on his categorisation. He had completed all core risk reduction work, and there had been no incidents of aggression or violence during the reporting period. An independent clinical psychologist concluded that his risk of reoffending if unlawfully at large had significantly reduced.

By their review, the Category A Review Team refused to downgrade G. The Category A Review Team relied on unproven security intelligence reports, which G disputed. A first claim was conceded so that a psychologist’s report could be reconsidered. A fresh decision then reached the same conclusion.

G lodged a further claim for judicial review of this fresh decision. By this second claim, he argued the decision was irrational, giving undue weight to unsubstantiated intelligence and insufficient weight to his progress, and that the refusal of an oral hearing was unfair. The refusal had also cost G a pre-tariff sift that could have led to open conditions.

Permission was granted on all grounds. By a separate review, the Secretary of State then downgraded G.

The claim became academic and was settled by consent, save for costs. In contested written submissions, G argued that he was the successful party given the outcome or, alternatively, that it had been reasonable to bring the claim on the above issues. The High Court took the unusual step of ordering the Secretary of State to pay his costs.

Rabah was instructed by Yasmin Karabasic and Andrew Sperling of SL5 Legal.