Share:

Supreme Court hears appeal on judicial proceedings immunity after disclosure of domestic abuse survivor’s confidential address

Can a survivor of domestic abuse seek compensation when her confidential address is revealed to her abuser during a court hearing?

Doughty Street Chambers barristers represent “Maya”, known in the proceedings as XGY, in an appeal heard by the Supreme Court on 21 and 22 October 2026. The case concerns the limits of judicial proceedings immunity and whether it prevents her claims against the Chief Constable of Sussex Police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) from proceeding.

After Maya left a violent and abusive relationship, threats against her and her family forced her to flee to a confidential location. An earlier police disclosure revealed her whereabouts to her former partner, forcing her to leave again and become homeless. That incident remains part of her claim against the police but is not the subject of this appeal.

Several months later, Maya gave the police her new address, emphasising that it must be kept from her former partner. The police included the address in a file sent to the CPS, without indicating that it was confidential. A separate domestic abuse checklist contained a warning, but the CPS said its advocate could not access it because of a known technical problem.

During a hearing concerning an unrelated alleged breach of bail, the CPS lawyer proposed a condition preventing Maya’s former partner from approaching the road where she lived. This revealed her location to him. Maya was forced to abandon her new home again and suffered psychiatric injury and financial losses, including lost earnings. She seeks damages for breach of confidence, misuse of private information and breaches of data protection law. 

Judicial proceedings immunity is a longstanding legal protection intended to support the administration of justice by allowing participants in court proceedings to speak freely without fear of being sued over what they say.

The police filed a defence, but the CPS applied to have the claims struck out on immunity grounds without filing a defence. The claims concerning the bail incident have not reached a trial. Maya argues that, without full disclosure of the relevant records, the chain of events by which her address and its confidentiality restriction were handled remains unexplained.

The High Court allowed the claims to proceed. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision ([2025] EWCA Civ 1230). It held that the CPS advocate’s words were protected because they were spoken in the ordinary course of court proceedings, including a bail hearing. It also extended immunity to the police’s preparation and transmission of the prosecution file, reasoning that liability for that work would undermine the advocate’s protection.

Although the Court of Appeal accepted that Maya’s address should not have been disclosed openly, it held that immunity barred the claims concerning that disclosure. It also held that the CPS was entitled to seek to strike out the claims without first filing a defence.

The Supreme Court has been asked to consider whether immunity bars claims concerning private / confidential information disclosed during a hearing, and whether it extends to the police’s earlier mishandling of that information. 

The case has important practical consequences for people who entrust sensitive information to police and prosecutors. For survivors of domestic and sexual abuse, keeping an address confidential can be essential to their safety. The appeal will help clarify how the law balances the protection needed for court proceedings with access to redress when disclosure causes harm. It concerns whether XGY’s claims can proceed to be considered on their merits.

Fiona Murphy KC, Sam Jacobs, Frederick Powell and Sean Sutherland represent XGY, instructed by Juliet Spender of Irwin Mitchell.  Judgment is awaited. Further details are available on the Supreme Court’s case page.