Share:

"Waiting for the axe to fall": Mukhtiar Singh wins unfair dismissal claim for Iceland Foods director forced out after husband joined Asda

Mukhtiar Singh, instructed by Simon Horsfield of Horsfield Menzies, acted for the Claimant, Nicola Rolph, who won her unfair dismissal claim against Iceland Foods Limited in the Employment Tribunal sitting in Cardiff. Employment Judge K Hunt heard the claim with two lay members. Iceland was represented by Daniel Tatton Brown KC of Littleton Chambers.

Ms Rolph was Iceland's Online Customer Director. She reported to her husband, the Group Chief Marketing, Customer and Digital Officer, who resigned to join Asda, a competitor. After he resigned, the Group CEO, Tarsem Dhaliwal OBE, said more than once that Ms Rolph would be "fired" if she shared confidential information. He also suggested she could not stay at Iceland once her husband began his new role. Within weeks, Iceland began an executive search for her role. Iceland said this was only a "mapping exercise", but the Tribunal found it was a recruitment exercise for her specific role.

In September 2024, Ms Rolph came back from holiday and went to a meeting with Mr Dhaliwal that lasted about six minutes. In that meeting he suggested it could be her "last meeting". Her IT access was cut off within minutes. A departure announcement she had not seen or agreed to was then sent to the business. Iceland argued that her employment ended by mutual agreement.

The Tribunal applied Riley v Direct Line Insurance Group [2023] EAT 118 and asked "who really terminated the contract?" It rejected Iceland's case and found that Mr Dhaliwal "seized an opportunity" and started the conversation about her leaving. It also found that the events of the previous weeks, taken together, put "undue pressure" on Ms Rolph, who was "waiting for the axe to inevitably fall". There had been no negotiation and no chance for her to take legal advice. The Tribunal decided she had been dismissed, not that she agreed to leave. Because Iceland gave no fair reason and followed no process, the dismissal was unfair.

The Tribunal accepted that Ms Rolph's notes of meetings were a fair and accurate record in key respects. It also noted that Iceland had kept no notes of its own. Remedy will be decided at a later hearing.

Law360 has reported on the decision here.