Share:

Albanian Extradition Win

Edward Fitzgerald KC and Abigail Bright successfully advised C how to advance C’s positive defence case in the Trial Court in Albania. 

The Ministry of Justice in the Republic of Albania sought C’s extradition for producing explosives, weapons, and firearms ammunition.

The Trial Court in Albania convicted C’s co-defendant and duly sentenced him.

C’s English lawyers worked with C’s trial lawyers in Albania to formulate convincing arguments framed by the Albanian Criminal Code. 

C’s arguments persuaded the Trial Prosecutor who filed a petition with the Trial Court to withdraw all criminal charges against C. 

The Trial Court declined to accede to the Trial Prosecutor’s petition and required that the Trial Prosecutor continue to prosecute C at a trial. 

The Trial Prosecutor, having committed the Office of the Prosecutor’s position to writing – specifically, the Prosecutor agreed with C that the Prosecution presented “insufficient evidence” against C – gave notice of the Prosecutor’s appeal to the Court of Appeal (a court of general jurisdiction) in Tirana.  C submitted written arguments to that Court which his English lawyers and his Albanian trial lawyers had developed.  The Court of Appeal refused and dismissed the Office of the Prosecutor’s appeal.  The Prosecutor gave notice of an appeal to the Supreme Court of the Republic of Albania, the highest judicial authority and final court of appeal in Albania.  The Office of the Prosecutor then withdrew its notice of its appeal and did not persist in applying to appeal, giving no reason or explanation for this.

The General Prosecution Office (Department of Jurisdictional Foreign Relations) removed C’s file from the original Trial Prosecutor. 

The Ministry of Justice in the Republic of Albania, having never withdrawn the extradition request for C, clarified that it still sought C’s extradition to try C for producing explosives, weapons, and firearms ammunition.

Edward Fitzgerald KC and Abigail Bright drafted written submissions on why pursuing this extradition request amounted to an abuse of this Court’s process.  The argument was that, when there is no real prospect of C being convicted, because the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction, it is abusive of this Court’s process for the Government of Albania still to ask this Court to determine its extradition request.  C submitted that Albania’s case against him in the Trial Court was bound to fail as hopeless in its analysis of the Criminal Code.

The extradition hearing was listed to occupy this week. 

The General Prosecution Office (Department of Jurisdictional Foreign Relations) gave notice that it would desist prosecuting C for producing explosives, weapons, and firearms ammunition.  The Ministry of Justice in the Republic of Albania withdraw its extradition request for C.

The Westminster Court discharged C from the extradition request and considered consequential ancillary applications.

By way of context, in April 2022, the First Instance Court in Albania had made C subject to arrest and pre-trial detention. However, C was bailed shortly after arriving in the UK and identifying as an asylum-seeker on Article 2 and Article 3 Convention grounds.  The Extradition Unit had opposed granting C bail in extradition proceedings, reasoning that C was an unmitigated flight risk. Defence counsel advised on how to secure bail in C’s asylum application proceedings awaiting a determination of C’s asylum claim. The First-tier Tribunal (Asylum and Immigration Chamber) was persuaded to bail C. The extradition judiciary consequently bailed C on the same conditions. 

This win shows the merits of extradition counsel having conferences with trial lawyers specifically to expose a weak prosecution case.

Extradition counsel can help foreign trial lawyers at the very start of extradition proceedings by sharing English law trial process expertise, jointly considering evidential sufficiency, and discussing proactive pursuit of applications to dismiss and European Convention rights. 

Edward Fitzgerald KC led Abigail Bright.

Ledi Bianku assisted as an expert witness.

Bilal Tanveer, Morgan Has Solicitors, instructed Counsel.